Mac Pigment Tan vs UD Toasted swatch

Hi, I just play around with my Mac pigment Tan and come with an idea to compared it with Urban Decay Naked Palette in Toasted. Both are pretty similar even tho Toasted more darker and pinker.
In real life when I look at Mac Tan it looks darker compared with UD Toasted, but when I swatch it's lighter than UD Toasted.
Here is the pictures :

Mac Pigment Tan

Compared it with UD Naked Palette in Toasted

From left : UD Half baked, Mac Tan, UD Toasted

From left : Mac Tan, Ud Toasted with flash. 

More closed up! Looks like Mac Tan (left) reflect shiny with flash.

From left : Mac woodwinked, Mac Tan, Ud Toasted. Bottom : Inglot P 406. Taken with flash.

More closed up without flash.

Hope this help you to decide what you like to buy from those eyeshadows. Have fun!

XoXo, 

Noniek